4 - A Vision for Transport
4.1 Introduction
This section describes the development of a Transport Vision for
B&NES based on the principles of the over-arching objectives
described in the previous section. In some senses it could be
described as ‘Utopian’ in that it describes a very high quality,
almost ideal state of transport within the authority area without
being unduly constrained by finance, traveller behaviour, transport
infrastructure. The Oversight Group felt that it was particularly
important to set out an unhindered Transport Vision of this nature,
to set an ultimate goal that should be sought. It was also
considered important to set a benchmark, against which, transport
strategies and conditions might be judged and monitored. It is
recognised that in the ‘real world’ that such a high level of
vision is very difficult to achieve; later sections describe the
problems and conflicts associated with this Vision and how a
practical transport strategy could be developed from it.
Section 4.2 summarises the key features of the Transport Vision,
which has been identified including both its primary and secondary
features. Section 4.3 describes the development of that Vision
through an examination of the Government’s 21 transport objectives
as set out in the GOMMMS framework.
4.2 Transport Vision Summary
Introduction
The following sections set out the main features of the
Transport Vision, which was developed largely by the Oversight
Group based on their extensive experience of transport planning
both in the UK and overseas. It is separated into those elements
that are considered to be of principal importance and those that
are considered to be secondary.
Principal Features of Transport Vision
With the Transport Vision in place, the transport networks would
efficiently serve the local economy allowing it to grow and prosper
without being significantly affected by traffic congestion. Links
to the national and international transport network would
facilitate the movement of public transport, goods and private
vehicles, and would provide for the travel needs of the workforce,
visitors and tourists.
Motorists in the City of Bath and the other urban areas within
B&NES would not experience significant traffic congestion, and
there would be a high level of journey time reliability.
Throughout B&NES there would be a high quality attractive
public transport network, with guaranteed levels of service and
accessibility that would enable tourists, residents and visitors to
undertake their desired activities without being dependent on the
private car. The levels of service and accessibility, and the way,
in which they were provided, would vary according to population
concentrations and location.
In those areas of quality townscape, landscape or historic
buildings, the settings of these features would not be degraded by
the intrusion of moving or parked vehicles, except those vehicles
essential to service the local activities.
In the centre of the urban areas, especially the historic core
of Bath, air quality would be maintained at levels well above
national guidelines and noise levels (from transport) would be kept
substantially below ‘annoyance levels’
Secondary Features of the Transport Vision
The public transport network would provide a travelling
experience, which is reliable, convenient and agreeable. Vehicles
and waiting environments would be clean, comfortable and secure.
The need for interchange would be minimised, but where necessary it
would be a low stress experience.
In residential areas, the level of transport activity would be
such that noise and air quality were fully compliant with national
standards. Trends in greenhouse gas emissions resulting from
transport activity throughout B&NES would make a positive
contribution to the achievement of national targets.
Communities that lie on major traffic routes would not suffer
from severance. Traffic would pass through their streets at a safe
speed, and there would be extensive crossing opportunities. There
would be a high level of user compliance with the rules and
regulations governing the use of the transport network and where
necessary, an adequate enforcement system would be available.
Underlying Requirements
Underpinning this vision is the recognition of the
following:
Firstly, that best UK practice in transportation planning and
traffic engineering should continue to be adopted in B&NES and
potential international experience exploited wherever appropriate;
Secondly, that adequate finance should be available to provide
the means through which the Vision can be achieved; and
Thirdly, that the threat posed by continued traffic growth,
particularly within the built-up areas, could severely compromise
the achievement of the Transport Vision.
4.3 Vision Development
The concepts of the Vision were developed and refined by
reviewing them against the 21 objectives of Government transport
policy. It has been structured in this form in order to have direct
relevance to Government assessment techniques This process is
summarised in Table 4.1
at the end of this chapter and the following sections describe its
development, in relation to each of the transport policy
objectives.
Vision Development – Environment
- Noise
Noise associated with transport, in particular road traffic, can
adversely affect a wide range of activities. It can be a particular
nuisance when it affects people in their homes and at night when it
can disturb sleep. Furthermore, people’s enjoyment of both the
built and natural environment can be seriously impaired by excess
noise from transport.
The vision therefore asserts that national noise protection
standards should be achieved in all residential areas within the
district and that within the historic core of Bath, a higher
standard should be sought, to ensure that residents and visitors
can enjoy the city’s heritage without being subject to excessive
noise.
- Local Air Quality
One of the major adverse side effects of traffic congestion
within B& NES is the impact that this has on air quality. Not
only does this harm the fabric of the built up areas but also
creates a risk to health.
The Vision therefore stipulates that national air quality
standards should be achieved throughout B& NES and within areas
of particular heritage value, such as the central area of Bath,
higher standards are sought in order to protect these
internationally recognised assets from degradation. It is also
important that future changes in air quality standards are closely
monitored as on going research reveals the longer-term effects of
exposure to pollutants, for example the growth in asthma in young
people.
- Greenhouse Gases
Transport is a major producer of ‘greenhouse gases’ through the
combustion of fossil fuels. These emissions are linked to climate
change and have been the subject of international treaties, in an
attempt to limit further global warming. It is considered essential
that the transport policies adopted for B&NES should contribute
positively towards national and international targets for reducing
the emission of greenhouse gases. As an environmentally conscious
authority, B&NES might consider more ambitious
targets.
- Landscape
- Landscape can be threatened by transport in 3 particular
ways:
- Through the construction of new infrastructure destroying
landscape features or settings;
- Through transport movements on existing transport
infrastructure, detracting from an existing landscape; and
- Through the by-products of transport movements: noise,
emissions, fuel spillages, etc degrading a
landscape.
The Vision therefore seeks
to minimise the adverse effects of transport on the landscape. In
terms of the scale of impact, new infrastructure is expected to
have a much greater impact than the other two forms of threat, and
as a result, particular care is needed in its design to minimise
landscape impacts.
- Townscape
Transport movements, stationary vehicles and the construction of
new transport infrastructure, all have the potential to adversely
affect townscapes by detracting from the built environment and
spoiling the urban experience within B&NES. This affects both
residents and visitors. The Vision therefore requires that the
relationship between people, traffic and places be such that
traffic and parked vehicles are not allowed to dominate the urban
environment within B&NES.
- Heritage of Historic Resources
Transport movements can affect historic resources in a number of
ways. Partly through the impact of new construction and partly
through on-going vehicle movements. With relatively little new
transport infrastructure envisaged, the focus of this element of
the Vision is on protecting heritage sites from the adverse effects
of vehicle movements. Whilst this crosses over a number of
sub-objectives, it recognises the need to protect heritage sites
from those impacts which would degrade these national/international
assets, including emissions, noise, vibration. It is also important
that their setting is not devalued by the scale of traffic
movements passing by or by surrounding them with parked
vehicles.
- Biodiversity
Much of the discussion relating to landscape can also be applied
to biodiversity, whilst the Vision recognises the importance of
wildlife and natural habitats, it does not consider that there is
likely to be the need to implement specific transport policies to
protect biodiversity which are not covered under other objectives.
The Vision would however require that biodiversity matters be fully
considered in the development of new transport
infrastructure.
- Water
Issues associated with groundwater, water quality and
watercourse management in relation to transport are significant
when considering the construction of new infrastructure but are of
less concern in relation to existing transport facilities. The
Vision therefore focuses on the need to ensure water quality is
fully taken into account in the design of new transport
infrastructure.
- Physical Fitness
The contribution of transport policy towards fitness in
B&NES, is anticipated to be very small and much better
considered by other policy areas.
- Journey Ambience
If B& NES is to be an attractive place to live, work and
visit, journeys to/from and within the authority must be a pleasant
experience. This covers all modes but the Vision places particular
emphasis on the need to improve public transport making it
convenient, reliable and stress-free.
Vision Development – Safety
- Accidents
The Vision envisages an on-going programme of work to reduce
transport accidents, building on best practice, continually
reviewing and monitoring accidents and tackling causes. It
recognises that for new developments, urban design can play an
important role in producing a safer streetscape by modifying
traditional relationships between motor vehicles, pedestrians and
cyclists. For existing urban and rural areas, changes to
streetscape and road layout are identified as being important in
transforming driver behaviour.
- Security
The Vision requires that, whatever means of transport is chosen
by the traveller for a journey in B&NES, it must be safe
throughout – free from threats to personal security. This requires
particular attention when considering waiting areas for public
transport, car parking, footpaths, and cycleways and during the
hours of darkness.
Vision Development – Economy
- Transport Economic Efficiency
It is recognised that congestion represents economic
inefficiency and has a number of adverse environmental side
effects. The Vision therefore requires that the traffic network
should operate with minimal practical levels of congestion and
provide very reliable journey times.
Whilst the elimination of congestion would also assist the
public transport user, there is also the need to ensure that public
transport journey times are competitive
- Reliability
One of the most important features of the Vision relates to
reliability. That includes journey time reliability for private
vehicles and, both journey time and service reliability for public
transport. This reliability benefits all types of activity within
B&NES but is of particular importance to the local economy
where uncertainties in journey time are considered to be an
existing problem and threat to future growth.
- Wider Economic Impacts
This objective relates to the effect of transport on areas with
specific economic problems – essentially re-generation areas.
Whilst B&NES does not contain any nationally designated
re-generation areas, the Vision recognises the variations in
economic conditions throughout B&NES and that in some areas the
local economy is relatively weak, with higher levels of
unemployment and lower income levels. This is particularly relevant
to some of the towns and villages south of Bath that previously had
economies based on traditional industries such as mining which have
now ceased.
The Vision recognises the need to improve access by car and
public transport from these areas to the major urban centres
Bristol and Bath, and also to the strategic transport networks. It
must be stressed however that these measures on their own are not
guaranteed to enhance the local economy but can assist in
combination with other economic development policies.
Vision Development - Accessibility
- Option Values
This is not considered to have relevance to the Transport Vision
for B&NES.
- Severance
It is recognised that in a number of communities within
B&NES, that the presence of major transport networks (mainly
highways) passing through those communities has a substantial
impact on the quality of life. These highway corridors can form
major barriers to pedestrian activity and degrade the urban
environment through the effects of noise and air quality discussed
above. The severance issue has a number of facets including the
physical barriers created by roads but also elements of fear and
intimidation associated with traffic travelling at speed close to
pedestrians.
To tackle these problems the Transport Vision requires
significant treatment of the streetscape within towns and villages
that are traversed by major highway routes to minimise these
severance effects, based on the principles set out in section
4.3.2.
- Access to the Transport System
A cornerstone of the Transport Vision is the need to provide
high level of public transport accessibility. The Vision is founded
on the concept of setting minimum public transport accessibility
standards, based on area type, to be applied throughout the whole
of B&NES. These standards will specify the
following:
- Maximum access time to public transport stops/stations;
- Minimum service frequencies to particular types of activity;
and
- Maximum public transport journey times to particular types of
activity.
- The area types are based on settlement size/population
density.
Vision Development – Integration
1.Transport Interchange
It is recognised that any degree of interchange within journeys
is an undesirable feature, which is perceived by the travelling
public as complicating a journey. These perceptions are compounded
by the general quality of transport interchanges within the UK (and
in B&NES) which generally have unattractive waiting
environments, poor facilities and lack of information for
travellers. Furthermore, there is frequently a lack of integration
between services of a particular mode and many problems of
integration between different modes, although bus-based park &
ride services are becoming increasingly well used.
The Transport Vision therefore requires the
following:
- Where possible ‘through’ public transport services should be
provided to allow direct door-to-door journeys to be made on a
single mode without need for interchange;
- Transport interchanges are of a very high quality with good
facilities and information; and
- Integration of services and between modes is of a high
standard.
2.Land-Use Policy
In general it is believed that the existing land-use policy
framework for B&NES, supports the Transport Vision. The
following land-use issues are important:
The need to attempt to balance employment and residential
development being conscious of the skillbase and employment
types;
Recognising the adverse effects of high property prices in Bath
and in some of the surrounding rural areas on the ability of local
workers to reside close to their place of work.; and
The attraction of people living in rural areas for quality of
life reasons, commuting into the urban centres for employment
placing significant strain on transport infrastructure.
3.Other Government Policies
The Transport Vision requires that Government policies address
in a holistic way the need to tackle growth in private car traffic,
particularly through its influence on the perceived costs of using
specific modes, through for example fuel pricing, vehicle taxation,
company car and other
legislation.
Conclusions
The development of the Transport Vision is summarised in
Table 4.1. It
demonstrates the extent to which each of the Government’s 21
Transport Sub-objectives have been considered within the overall
Vision composition.
Table 4.1 – Transport Vision
Development
| Criteria |
Sub-Criteria |
Form of Vision |
| Environment |
Noise |
National standards should be attained in all residential areas.
The centre of Bath should strive for a better standard. |
|
|
Local air quality |
National standards should be attained in all residential areas.
The centre of Bath should strive for a better
standard. |
|
Greenhouse gases |
All areas should achieve national targets. |
|
Landscape |
Minimise the adverse effects of transport on the
landscape. |
|
Townscape |
Stationary and moving vehicles detract from the physical
appearance of attractive buildings. The impact of transport should
be reduced such that it does not inhibit enjoyment of features of
the built environment, which exhibit special quality. |
|
Heritage of historic resources |
Stationary and moving vehicles detract from the physical
appearance of attractive buildings and monuments. The impact of
transport should be reduced such that it does not inhibit enjoyment
of historic resources, which exhibit special quality. |
|
Biodiversity |
Biodiversity matters should be fully considered in the
development of new transport infrastructure. |
|
Water |
Water quality should be fully taken into account in the design
of new transport infrastructure. |
|
Physical fitness |
Not applicable. |
|
Journey ambience |
Journeys should be reliable, convenient and
agreeable. |
| Safety |
Accidents |
There should be an on-going programme of work to reduce
transport accidents, to build on best practice, to ensure continual
review and monitoring and to tackle the causes. Safer streetscapes
in new developments through urban design. Transformation of driver
behaviour in existing urban and rural areas through changes to
streetscape and road layout. |
|
|
Security |
Journeys should be free from threats to personal security from
end to end |
| Economy |
Transport economic efficiency |
All areas should be free from congestion, and vehicles should
enjoy a guaranteed minimum peak hour speed. |
|
|
Reliability |
Journey time reliability is dealt with under journey ambience
and transport economic efficiency. Operational reliability should
be improved. |
|
Wider economic impacts |
The transport system should be able to facilitate economic
activity without having an undesirable impact on
congestion. |
| Accessibility |
Option values |
Not applicable. |
|
|
Severance |
Must be reduced to insignificant levels where it
occurs |
|
Access to the transport system |
There should be a guaranteed minimum level of access to the
transport system. |
| Integration |
Transport interchange |
Should be minimised as far as possible. Where it is necessary,
it should be efficient and reliable. |
|
|
Land-use policy |
The existing land-use policy of B&NES supports the Transport
Vision. Key issues include attempting to balance employment and
residential development with skillbase and employment types;
recognising the adverse effects of high property prices on local
workers attempts to reside close to their place of employment;
addressing the strain placed on the transport infrastructure by
people living in rural areas for quality of life reasons, commuting
into the urban centres for employment. |
|
Other Government Policy |
Enforcement should be enhanced to a level where compliance helps
to achieve the vision. |